As a Texas attorney who frequently handles contract dispute matters involving non-compete agreements, one of the questions that I am asked more than any other (by both employers and employees) is:

Are non-compete agreements enforceable in Texas?
The answer is: Yes, they can be. Texas law makes non-compete agreements enforceable if they are:
- Accompanied by or part of an otherwise enforceable agreement;
- Supported by valid consideration (ie. something of value given to the employee), and;
- Reasonable in time, geographic scope, and activities to be restrained.
If these elements exist a Texas employer may be able to effectively enforce the terms of a non-compete agreement to protect company goodwill and confidential information.
Contact attorney Robert Wood for help with your noncompete issue.
That being said, Texas law generally disfavors contracts and arrangements that restrict employee mobility. The Texas Free Enterprise and Antitrust Act of 1983 states that āEvery contract, combination, or conspiracy in restraint of trade or commerce is unlawful.ā However, the Texas legislature has carved out an exception to this, by allowing non-compete agreements to be enforceable in certain circumstances.
Whether you are an employee or an employer in Texas, I can help you understand the enforceability of your specific non-compete clause.
Contact me anytime to set up a time to speak with me for answers.
- Click here for answers to questions about hiring me to help with your Texas non-compete issue.
- Click here to read real client reviews.
- Continue reading for a more in-depth explanation of the enforceability of non compete agreements in Texas.
To Be Enforceable in Texas, Non-Competes Must Be Reasonable in Scope
Texas courts have recognized that overly broad restrictions on employee mobility are harmful to the free market. Accordingly, not all non-compete agreements (i.e., restrictive covenants) are enforceable in Texas. To be valid under Texas law, a covenant not to compete must be āancillary to an otherwise enforceable agreement.ā
Then, the restrictions must be reasonable in scope.
What Does āOtherwise Enforceable Agreementā Mean?
The āotherwise enforceable agreementā requirement simply means that both parties to the contract must have made binding promises. In the 1990s and 2000s, whether an āotherwise enforceable agreementā existed was the subject of much litigationāespecially in the context of an at-will employee.
An at-will employee in Texas would typically contend that any consideration promised by the employerāsuch as specialized trainingāwas āillusory,ā because the employee could theoretically be fired before receiving it. For years, this was an argument that Texas courts accepted.
The Sheshunoff Decision: A Turning Point
That all changed in 2006, when the Texas Supreme Court issued its Sheshunoff opinion. There, the court held that a promise to an at-will employee could be part of a valid agreement once the consideration was actually provided.
This was an important holding, as it precluded a substantial amount of potential litigation related to when the consideration for a non-compete was given.
Marsh USA and the Shift Toward Enforceability
Several other Texas Supreme Court cases enhanced the enforceability of non-compete agreements, culminating in the Marsh USA case in 2011. There, the court held that the consideration given by the employerāsuch as confidential information or access to clientsādid not have to āgive riseā to the need to restrain competition. Rather, the consideration had to be āreasonably relatedā to the need to restrain competition.
In the right case, consideration such as:
- Confidential information,
- Trade secrets, and
- The need to protect goodwill
could meet this standard.
Balancing Contract Freedom and Free Market Competition
In reaching this result, the Texas Supreme Court emphasized that the Texas Constitution protects the freedom to contract. But it also reaffirmed that non-competes must be narrowly tailored. The court noted that āunreasonable limitationsā could āhinder legitimate competition.ā
In his concurring opinion in Marsh USA, Justice Willett cautioned judges to carefully evaluate āwhen competition becomes unfair competition and when a restraint becomes an unreasonable or unnecessarily restrictive restraint.ā Texas law, he said, ādoes not allow protectionism,ā and non-competes cannot protect against āthe bruises of ordinary competition.ā
SoāAre Non-Competes Enforceable in Texas?
The answer, as with many legal questions, is: it depends.
What an employee bound by a non-compete really wants to know is: What will happen to me if I violate a non-compete in Texas?
What Will Happen to Me if I Violate a Non Compete Agreement in Texas?
There is no easy answer to that question. The contract itself must be reviewed, as well as the individual circumstances.
Also, a non-compete agreement, even if supported by valid consideration, must be reasonable in scope. Some non competes are unreasonable, because the term of the restriction, the geographic scope, or the scope of the activity to be restrained is too broad.
Even if a non compete is valid under Texas law, that does not mean that an employer suing to enforce the agreement will automatically prevail. An employee bound by a non-compete may have various defenses. The employerās unclean hands, for example, may be a defense to injunctive relief. Or, an employer seeking a temporary injunction may not have suffered irreparable harm, or it may have an adequate legal remedy. The facts of each case must be carefully analyzed.
Get answers from an experienced Texas noncompete attorney
We have assisted many employees who are bound by non-competes. We are familiar with the law governing these agreements. We also have substantial practical experience, gained from both inside and outside of the courtroom. Also, because we also represent companies, we know how employers tend to view violations of these agreements.
If you are party to a noncompete agreement or have a legal matter involving a non compete in Texas,Ā contact us today.
FAQ: Hiring Me to Help with Your Noncompete Issue
I Have a Noncompete Agreement That I Need to Have Reviewed. What Is Your Process?
I will review the agreement and then we will set up a time to talk.
Will the Conversation Occur via Telephone or in Person?
I conduct 99% of my consultations via phone or Zoom (Zoom is best).
What Will We Talk About?
I will ask questions so that I can learn the details of your situation. I will discuss the law with you and the facts of your situation. I will work with you to make the best decision for you, by assessing possible risks and rewards.
How Long Will We Talk?
As long as necessary. Typically, 30-45 minutes or so.
Is That Long Enough?
Yes. I donāt waste time, and since I have done over 1,000 noncompete consultations, I know the questions to ask, and I am good at quickly analyzing a situation.
What if I Think of Another Question After Our Conversation? Is There an Additional Charge to Talk With You Again?
Typically, there would not be another charge. Of course, if I end up spending substantial time, I will have to go back on the clock, but an additional few minutes of questions will not be a problem.
What if I Need You to Negotiate With My Employer or Send a Letter for Me? Is There an Additional Charge for That?
Typically, yes. But it may not be necessary for me to engage with your employer. Letās talk and determine whether that is necessary. If it becomes necessary for me to communicate with your employer, again, I donāt waste timeāI am able to get things done efficiently.
Do You Mainly Represent Employees or Employers?
Both. I have advised many employees and have represented many employees in litigation.
What Is Your Usual Turnaround on Reviewing an Agreement and Having a Consultation?
I can act quickly, usually within a day or two (and sometimes the same day). And I am often available at night and on Saturday.
My Cousin Steve Says That Texas Is a āRight to Work State,ā and That Noncompete Agreements Are Not Enforceable Here. Are You Sure I Need to Talk With You?
You do need to talk with me. āRight to workā has nothing to do with noncompete agreements. It simply means that you canāt be forced to join a labor union.
When I Signed My Noncompete, I Wasnāt Given a Choice on Whether to Do So. Plus, I Was Not Paid Any Money, nor Was I Given a Promotion. Do We Really Need to Talk?
Yes, we do.
Since I Signed a Noncompete, Is It Really Worthwhile to Talk With You? Should I Just Comply With It?
This is a strange area of the law. Itās often not as simple as, āYou signed it, you must comply.ā The individual facts of each case have to be analyzed. Plus, given my 25+ years of experience, I have a good feel for which situations will end up in litigation and which ones will not.
Do I Really Need You? Canāt I Just Watch Some Videos Online?
You can find a lot of information online. What youāll get from me, though, is an individualized assessment of your situation. Over the years, Iāve gotten good at distinguishing between situations that look safe and ones that look dangerous. I wonāt just tell you what the law is. Iāll give you a recommendation on what to do, based on your individual circumstances.
I Work for the Worst Boss in the World. I Know He Will Sue Me. Can You Really Help?
I hear this all the time. But thereās a big difference between threatening to sue someone and actually doing it. Iāll work with you to assess whether your boss is bluffing.
What Is Your Main Objective for the Individuals With Whom You Work?
To keep them out of trouble. My goal is that we will talk once and you will get some good advice so that you donāt have to call me again. But I also want to keep you from just ālaying downāāI want to come up with a game plan that allows you to get out of a bad situation (if you are in one) and get on with your career.
If My Employer Sues Me, Will You Represent Me?
That would be a separate engagement. But I have handled many noncompete lawsuits, on both sides of the docket, and have had a lot of success.
I Am a Physician. Do You Have Experience Working With Doctors?
Absolutely. Some of my best results have been on behalf of individual physicians. I have reviewed hundreds of physician contracts. I have a good feel for whether a particular contract is āfriendlyā or āunfriendlyā for the physician, and because of my experience, I know the pitfalls to look for.
Is There Anything Unique About Physician Contracts?
Yes. There are certain legal requirements that only apply to physicians.
Further Reading: Texas Noncompete Articles by Robert Wood
Want to learn more? Browse Texas non-compete and contract dispute articles, written by Attorney Robert Wood:
- Are Texas Noncompete Agreements Enforceable if the Employee Is Fired?
- Everything You Need to Know About Texas Noncompete Geographic Limitations
- 16 Questions People Ask Most About Texas Noncompete Agreements
- Federal Judge Halts FTC’s Noncompete Ban
- FTC Noncompete Ban in Jeopardy, Likely Unlawful
- FTC Votes to Ban Noncompetes, but Employees Should Proceed with Caution
- No, the Biden Administration Has Not Banned Non-Compete Agreements
- Sample Texas Noncompete Agreement (and Why Using a Free Template Is a Bad Idea)
- Calculating a Noncompete’s Geographic Scope: By Driving Distance, Or “As The Crow Flies”?
- Do Texas noncompete agreements apply to independent contractors?
- Do I need to have my employees sign non compete agreements?
- Can A Noncompete Be Extended If It Is Violated?
- Who Can Get Attorneysā Fees in a Non-Compete Action?
- Possible Tort Claim Not Sufficient Consideration for Noncompete in Texas
- Money for a Noncompete in Texas?